Top Gear: USA vs UK

Ok, so lets see how everyone really feels about Top Gears second (or third, forth?) son. Top Gear USA had humongous shoes to borrow and fill, and it's a credit to them that they've lasted this long. So now that the show has had a little time to find itself and be the best Top Gear USA that it can be what's the consensus? Do you love it? hate it? have your mind made up without actually watching any of it?

Part 2

Now every time there's a discussion about said Top Gear there's always numerous comments about how much better the show would be if they replaced [one of the three]. Funny thing is every one seems to think one of them needs to go, but nobody can agree on who. So who do you think is the weakest link?