Carmax Showdown: Super Sedans

1. 2007 Mercedes-Benz E63 AMG

Carmax Showdown: Super Sedans

Carmax Showdown: Super Sedans

2. 2006 BMW M5

Carmax Showdown: Super Sedans

Carmax Showdown: Super Sedans

3. 2009 Cadillac CTS V

Carmax Showdown: Super Sedans

I chose all automatic black cars to keep this equal, so which of the three do you DeMuro?