Car Insurance in CA, who to go with?

I'll thank you in advance for the help with the photo dump at the end.

Background: I'm 25, clean driving record with zero tickets, accidents or claims of any kind. To date, I have had Amica insurance for 2 years (auto + renters) and it has been OK. I recently turned 25 and I was expecting a lowered rate, low and behold...no dice.

I shopped around, even did a quick Geico quote and it looks like I can save about $500 a year which is not chump change. Quote is for $300K collision, $100K accident, $500 deductible on a 2013 Scion FR-S

Looking to see what companies people have had positive experiences with! Thanks

Car Insurance in CA, who to go with?

Car Insurance in CA, who to go with?