Would You Rather: Gated Manual EditionS

Random question inspired by learning the new small Lambo will not have a manual option :(

Would You Rather: Gated Manual EditionS

So after a quick look at Autotrader I wonder if I was a rich gentleman what would I choose. The arguably better looking (interior & exterior) and faster 2009 560-4 with only 1.5k on the clock ….

Would You Rather: Gated Manual EditionS

…. for a 160k. Or save a lot of money and spend 100k on a …..

Would You Rather: Gated Manual EditionS

….. 2009 R8 4.2 with only 3k on the clock?

Would You Rather: Gated Manual EditionS

So do you pony up and get the Italian stallion, or be sensible and settle with 420hp in the grey German?

(Sorry I don't know how to add a poll)